Ive built dozens of rigs but the Gen5 premium on Z790 feels like a total scam. My logic was future-proofing this editing build for my Oregon studio, but $280 for a T700 is nuts. Is a fast Gen4 like the SN850X still the best value for these boards since Gen5 is so overpriced?
> the Gen5 premium on Z790 feels like a total scam To add to the point above: it really is. Gen5 thermals are a mess. I'd suggest the SK Hynix Platinum P41 2TB NVMe for efficiency. Or maybe the Kingston KC3000 2TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe. It uses the Phison E18 controller. Very solid. Just be careful with the double-sided PCB layout in tight slots. Both are much better studio options than overpriced Gen5 drives.
Unfortunately, the current state of Gen5 storage is a massive letdown. Ive been building for ages and these new drives feel like they were rushed to market without thinking about longevity. The heat they put out is a real safety concern for the rest of your components tbh. If you're doing heavy editing, you need something that wont throttle or fail during a long render. Check these out instead:
> Is a fast Gen4 like the SN850X still the best value for these boards since Gen5 is so overpriced? Honestly, you hit the nail on the head. In my experience building high-end editing rigs, you wont even notice the difference between Gen4 and Gen5 in real-world timeline scrubbing. Those Gen5 drives run way too hot and the price premium is just plain silly right now. Over the years Ive seen these hardware cycles and Gen4 is definitely the sweet spot for Z790 builds. I personally recommend the Western Digital WD_BLACK SN850X 2TB NVMe SSD as it is rock solid and handles high bit-rate footage without breaking a sweat. If you want another option, the Samsung 990 Pro 2TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe SSD is also fantastic and super reliable for long-term professional use. Save that extra cash for more RAM... itll serve your Oregon studio way better than an overpriced Gen5 drive would tho. Lemme know if you need any help with the cooling setup or heatsink choices!
Just saw this and I gotta say, you're 100% right about that Gen5 tax. It's wild how much they're asking for speeds you only see in synthetic benchmarks. I've been building workstations since the old SATA SSD days and the jump from Gen3 to Gen4 felt massive, but Gen4 to Gen5? It's basically a heat contest at this point. I totally agree with the point about real-world feel. In my experience over the years, I've found that focusing on specific technical specs matters way more for an editing rig than the generation label on the box. I used to be obsessed with the highest numbers until I realized my renders were failing because of thermal throttling on those first-gen fast drives. Here's what I look for now: