What is the best 4K...
 
Notifications
Clear all

What is the best 4K monitor for professional video editing?

5 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
17 Views
0
Topic starter

My old setup just completely blacked out on me this morning and I am literally shaking because I have this huge documentary deadline for a client here in Chicago by next Friday. I dont have time to wait around or mess with something that isnt color accurate right out of the box because the color grading phase is starting and I am totally lost. I have been staring at reviews all morning until my eyes hurt and I am torn between two main options but I cant pull the trigger.

Im looking at:

  • BenQ SW321C
  • ASUS ProArt PA329C
  • Maybe the Dell U3223QE if I want to save some cash but I dont know if it cuts it for pro work

The BenQ seems like the safe bet for video but its right at the top of my $2,000 budget and honestly I am worried about the screen uniformity issues I read about on some forums. The Asus is a bit cheaper which would let me buy a better external calibrator tool but I keep seeing mixed things about their quality control and I really cant afford to be shipping things back and forth right now. I need something that can handle 4K HDR stuff without showing weird ghosting since I am doing a lot of fast cuts in Davinci Resolve. Which one is actually gonna last? I need to order this by tonight or I am totally screwed...


5 Answers
11

Just seeing this now but are you outputting via a DeckLink card or just your GPU? If accuracy is your main worry, the BenQ SW321C 32 inch 4K UHD IPS is the only real choice here. The 10-bit panel and hardware calibration are amazing for keeping things stable so you wont have to stress about color drift mid-project. Its way more reliable than that Asus lottery! Honestly, dont sweat the price, it just works.


10

The BenQ SW321C 32 inch 4K IPS is amazing! Its 10-bit hardware LUT totally beats the ASUS ProArt PA329C 32 inch 4K. Skip the Dell, the BenQ uniformity is way better for docs!


3

I definitely agree with Otter, the BenQ SW321C is the safer play for that hardware LUT stability. The ASUS ProArt PA329C might look fine on a spec sheet but the panel lottery is real and you dont have time for that. I remember back when I was setting up a small studio space in Lincoln Park... we had this massive rack of gear and the cooling was just non-existent. It was a total disaster.

  • old server fans are louder than jet engines
  • we used to keep the door open even in winter
  • someone once left a sandwich on the intake The smell of toasted ham was stuck in those filters for weeks and it basically ruined my concentration for the entire grading process of that short film. I think we ended up having to replace the whole filtration system because it was just gross. Anyway lol sorry kinda went off topic there.


2
  • my current screen works okay but the backlight bleed is kinda annoying tbh - are you grading for web or broadcast?

1

Honestly, those choices are a bit underwhelming if you are actually trying to push a professional grade for a documentary. I have had some pretty bad luck with the uniformity on the ASUS ProArt PA329C and unfortunately, the quality control is just as spotty as people say. It is frustrating to spend that much and still see backlight bleed in the corners when you are trying to judge shadows in Davinci. The BenQ SW321C is better for stills, but for video, the response times always felt sluggish to me, which is a mess for fast cuts. Before you commit to anything today, I need to know:

  • are you grading for web or are you actually aiming for a broadcast HDR standard?
  • what hardware are you using to get the signal out of your computer? Its a tough spot to be in with a deadline, but buying one of these without a dedicated I/O setup means you're still fighting your OS color management. Testing the Dell U3223QE was another letdown since the contrast just isnt accurate enough for a final pass. It is disappointing that so many 'pro' displays still struggle with basic panel consistency right out of the box. You really need to be careful here because none of these are truly ready for high-end delivery without a lot of extra work.


Share: